Katherine Mueller
Katherine Mueller

Obituary of Katherine Mueller

With hearts heavy yet full of love, we commemorate the life of Katherine "Kathy" Mueller who departed this world peacefully in the comfort of her home in Warren, New Jersey, surrounded by her loving family on Monday, January 29, 2024. At 76, Kathy's final days were a testament to her enduring strength, gracefully facing a challenging battle with cancer, with the constant support of her family and friends.

Born in Orange, New Jersey, to James and Beatrice Mahon on August 9, 1947, Kathy’s journey was one of warmth, resilience, and boundless love.  Her roots in Orange and later in Verona laid the groundwork for a life marked by community connection and familial bonds.  Kathy, a proud Verona High School graduate, then embarked on a distinguished career at American National Bank in Montclair. Her dedication and meticulous work ethic were recognized with a well-earned promotion to Assistant Manager, a role she held with grace and professionalism.

The narrative of Kathy’s life is incomplete without the mention of a chance encounter at Dodd’s Bar with Edward Mueller in 1969.  Despite a missed opportunity to exchange numbers, fate intervened, and nine months later, they met again, ensuring to not let the moment slip by. Their love blossomed into a profound love story, celebrated with their wedding on September 17, 1972, at Our Lady of the Lake in Verona.  Their bond, nurtured through shared dreams and mutual support, stood as a testament to true love and partnership.

Choosing to focus on her family, Kathy embraced her new role as a mother and homemaker. Kathy created a sanctuary of warmth and joy, and dedicated herself to raising four wonderful children. Her home quickly filled with love, laughter, comfort, and cherished memories. Kathy's caring nature knew no bounds, whether it was caring for her aging mother, helping with adored grandchildren, or extending a helping hand to friends in need.

Kathy's zest for life was reflected in her diverse interests and adventures. A lover of history and travel, she explored the world with her family, from cruises to England, Russia, the Mediterranean, and the Caribbean to adventures visiting family in New Zealand and Australia.  Her passion for genealogy led her to Ireland where she uncovered and celebrated her own Irish heritage. A talented crocheter and knitter, Kathy was an active member of several local knitting groups, sharing her skills and fostering friendships. Her collections of teapots and dolls were a testament to her appreciation for beauty and craftsmanship. Her beach home in Chadwick Beach, Toms River, was a cherished retreat for summer family gatherings.  Her spirit was reflected in her love of lighthouses as Kathy was a beacon of light and love to all who knew her.

Kathy's legacy, love, and memories will be forever cherished by her devoted husband, Edward; her beloved children, Laura Connolly (Thomas), Christina Mueller (Jonathan Loane), Michael Mueller (Soirette Marrero), and Melissa Leitner (Martin); and her six adored grandchildren, Ryan, Megan, Caroline, Matthew, Valerie, and Mia.   She is predeceased by her parents, James and Beatrice Mahon, and her brothers, James and William Mahon.  

We remember Kathy as a loving wife, mother, grandmother, daughter, and friend whose kindness, strength, and love leaves an indelible mark on the hearts of those she touched, and her memory will forever be a source of comfort and inspiration. We honor her journey by celebrating the remarkable woman she was and the countless ways she enriched our lives.

A visitation will be held on Friday, February 2, 2024, from 4:00 to 8:00 p.m., at Higgins Home for Funerals, 752 Mountain Blvd., Watchung, NJ. A funeral mass will be celebrated at 10:00 a.m., on Saturday, February 3, 2024, at St. Mary's Stony Hill Church, 225 Mountain Blvd., Watchung, New Jersey, followed by entombment at Somerset Hills Memorial Park in Basking Ridge, NJ.

The family kindly requests memorial donations be made to Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in memory of Katherine "Kathy" Mueller. This gesture honors Kathy’s lifelong commitment to nurturing and giving, ensuring her legacy of love continues to touch lives.


Visitation at the Funeral Home

4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Friday, February 2, 2024
Higgins Home for Funerals
752 Mountain Blvd.
Watchung, New Jersey, United States

Funeral Mass at St. Mary's Stony-Hill R.C. Church

10:00 am
Saturday, February 3, 2024
St. Mary's Stony Hill Church
225 Mountain Boulevard
Watchung, New Jersey, United States

Final Resting Place

Somerset Hills Memorial Park
95 Mount Airy Road
Basking Ridge, New Jersey, United States
Share Your Memory of